Futureproof - Bulletproof concurrent.futures

concurrent.futures is amazing, but it's got some sharp edges that have bit me many times in the past.

Futureproof is a thin wrapper around it addressing some of these problems and adding some usability features.

Features:

• Monitoring: a summary of recent completed tasks is logged by default.
• Fail fast: errors cause the main thread to raise an exception and stop by default.
• Error policy: the user can decide whether to raise, log or completely ignore errors on tasks.
• Backpressure control: large collections of tasks are consumed lazily as the executor completes tasks, drastically reducing memory consumption and improving responsiveness in these situations.

Current status: Alpha

The API is subject to change, any changes will be documented in the changelog.

Futureproof was designed to wrap ThreadPoolExecutor, however version 0.2+ includes limited support ProcessPoolExecutor but only for Python3.7+.

concurrent.futures problems?

Let's have a look at the canonical example for ThreadPoolExecutor:

import concurrent.futures
import urllib.request

URLS = ['http://www.foxnews.com/',
        'http://www.cnn.com/',
        'http://europe.wsj.com/',
        'http://www.bbc.co.uk/',
        'http://some-made-up-domain-that-definitely-does-not-exist.com/']

# Retrieve a single page and report the URL and contents
def load_url(url, timeout):
    with urllib.request.urlopen(url, timeout=timeout) as conn:
        return conn.read()

# We can use a with statement to ensure threads are cleaned up promptly
with concurrent.futures.ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=5) as executor:
    # Start the load operations and mark each future with its URL
    future_to_url = {executor.submit(load_url, url, 60): url for url in URLS}
    for future in concurrent.futures.as_completed(future_to_url):
        url = future_to_url[future]
        try:
            data = future.result()
        except Exception as exc:
            print('%r generated an exception: %s' % (url, exc))
        else:
            print('%r page is %d bytes' % (url, len(data)))

Just to reiterate, this is amazing, the fact that the barrier of entry for multithreading is this small is really a testament to the great work done by Brian Quinlan and the core Python developers.

However, I see two problems with this:

1. The boilerplate. We need to enter a context manager, call submit manually keeping track of the futures and its arguments, call as_completed which actually returns an iterator, call result on the future remembering to handle the exception.
2. It's surprising. Why do we need to get the result in order to raise? What if we don't expect it to raise? We probably want to know as soon as possible.

If you run this code you get the following output (at the time of this writing):

'http://some-made-up-domain-that-definitely-does-not-exist.com/' generated an exception: <urlopen error [Errno 8] nodename nor servname provided, or not known>
'http://www.foxnews.com/' page is 248838 bytes
'http://www.bbc.co.uk/' page is 338658 bytes
'http://www.cnn.com/' page is 991167 bytes
'http://europe.wsj.com/' page is 970346 bytes

Which is perfect. How does futureproof compare?

executor = futureproof.FutureProofExecutor(max_workers=5)
with futureproof.TaskManager(executor) as tm:
    for url in URLS:
        tm.submit(load_url, url, 60)
    for task in tm.as_completed():
        print("%r page is %d bytes" % (task.args[0], len(task.result)))

That looks quite similar, there's an executor and a task manager. submit and as_completed are methods on it and there's no try..except. If we run it we get:

'http://www.foxnews.com/' page is 248838 bytes
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "/Users/yeray/.pyenv/versions/3.7.3/lib/python3.7/urllib/request.py", line 1317, in do_open
    encode_chunked=req.has_header('Transfer-encoding'))
  ... omitted traceback output ...
socket.gaierror: [Errno 8] nodename nor servname provided, or not known

Notice that futureproof raised the exception immediately and everything stopped, as you would've expected in normal non-threaded Python, no surprises.

If we prefer futureproof gives you the option to log or even ignore exceptions using error policies. Say we want to log the exceptions:

logging.basicConfig(
    level=logging.INFO,
    format="[%(asctime)s %(thread)s] %(message)s",
    datefmt="%H:%M:%S",
)

executor = futureproof.FutureProofExecutor(max_workers=5)
with futureproof.TaskManager(executor, error_policy="log") as tm:
    for url in URLS:
        tm.submit(load_url, url, 60)

    for task in tm.as_completed():
        if not isinstance(task.result, Exception):
            print("%r page is %d bytes" % (task.args[0], len(task.result)))

Note we've added a check to only print the result in case it's not an exception, this outputs:

'http://www.foxnews.com/' page is 251088 bytes
[12:09:15 4350641600] Task Task(fn=<function load_url at 0x1029ef1e0>, args=('http://some-made-up-domain-that-definitely-does-not-exist.com/', 60), kwargs={}, result=URLError(gaierror(8, 'nodename nor servname provided, or not known')),
 complete=True) raised an exception
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "/Users/yeray/.pyenv/versions/3.7.3/lib/python3.7/urllib/request.py", line 1317, in do_open
    encode_chunked=req.has_header('Transfer-encoding'))
    ... omitted long traceback ...
  File "/Users/yeray/.pyenv/versions/3.7.3/lib/python3.7/urllib/request.py", line 1319, in do_open
    raise URLError(err)
urllib.error.URLError: <urlopen error [Errno 8] nodename nor servname provided, or not known>
'http://some-made-up-domain-that-definitely-does-not-exist.com/' generated an exception: <urlopen error [Errno 8] nodename nor servname provided, or not known>
'http://www.bbc.co.uk/' page is 339087 bytes
'http://www.cnn.com/' page is 991167 bytes
[12:09:16 123145404444672] 5 task completed in the last 1.18 second(s)
'http://europe.wsj.com/' page is 970880 bytes

Note we only had to configure logging and pass the appropriate error policy, everything else was taken care for us. You can also choose to ignore exceptions completely and manage them yourself accessing result, which is the workflow when using concurrent.futures.

as_completed?

If you think about it, why do we need as_completed?

The answer is for monitoring and error handling.

If we had loads of URLs, you don't want to wait until all URLs are back to show output, it could take ages. But really it just adds complexity to the code. What does the example look like if you don't use as_completed?

with concurrent.futures.ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=5) as executor:
    future_to_url = {executor.submit(load_url, url, 60): url for url in URLS}

for future, url in future_to_url.items():
    try:
        data = future.result()
    except Exception as exc:
        print("%r generated an exception: %s" % (url, exc))
    else:
        print("%r page is %d bytes" % (url, len(data)))

Which is arguably more readable, however, it has a subtle difference: there's no output until all the futures are complete. If you imagine tasks taking longer you're left wondering if things are even working at all.

Let's compare to the futureproof version:

executor = futureproof.FutureProofExecutor(max_workers=5)
with futureproof.TaskManager(executor, error_policy="ignore") as tm:
    for url in URLS:
        tm.submit(load_url, url, 60)

for task in tm.completed_tasks:
    if isinstance(task.result, Exception):
        print("%r generated an exception: %s" % (task.args[0], task.result))
    else:
        print("%r page is %d bytes" % (task.args[0], len(task.result)))

[12:40:28 123145393414144] Starting executor monitor
[12:40:29 123145393414144] 5 task completed in the last 1.01 second(s)
[12:40:29 123145393414144] Shutting down monitor...
'http://www.foxnews.com/' page is 252016 bytes
'http://some-made-up-domain-that-definitely-does-not-exist.com/' generated an exception: <urlopen error [Errno 8] nodename nor servname provided, or not known>
'http://www.cnn.com/' page is 992648 bytes
'http://www.bbc.co.uk/' page is 338987 bytes
'http://europe.wsj.com/' page is 969285 bytes

futureproof defaults to logging monitoring information on the tasks so you always know if things are working. Note how the task manager exposes completed_tasks allowing easy access to the results without having to manually keep track of futures. Finally, as mentioned previously, you're also in total control over exception handling so you don't need to add code for that either.

That's not that big a deal..

Quite, these are fairly minor problems that we can work around manually using concurrent.futures. But as you start to scale the number of jobs a more subtle issue creeps in.

Under the hood concurrent.futures uses queues to store the jobs, including the function and its arguments. It does it right at the start, for all the jobs, which means that, in high job count situations, the queue grows very large and the main thread can hang and become unresponsive.

A simple example:

def custom_sum(a, b):
    time.sleep(0.1)
    return a + b


with concurrent.futures.ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=2) as ex:
    fn = partial(custom_sum, b=1)
    ex.map(fn, range(1_000_000_000))

Running this simple function with a billion times will result in the CPU maxing out and the memory usage will increase dramatically. Again, this all happens without any logging or output, and, to make things worse, a keyboard interrupt will not immediately exit so you'll have to hit it repeatedly forcing the threads to exit in an unclean state.

Let's compare this to futureproof:

# same function as before
ex = futureproof.ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=2)
with futureproof.TaskManager(
    ex, error_policy=futureproof.ErrorPolicyEnum.RAISE
) as tm:
    fn = partial(custom_sum, b=1)
    tm.map(fn, range(1_000_000_000))

Almost immediately you will see logging like:

[15:15:21 4632346048] Starting backpressure test with 1,000,000,000 tasks
[15:15:21 4632346048] You may KeyboardInterrupt at any point and the executor will stop almost immediately
[15:15:21 123145413025792] Starting executor monitor
[15:15:22 123145413025792] 2 task completed in the last 0.20 second(s)
[15:15:22 123145413025792] 1 task completed in the last 0.10 second(s)
[15:15:22 123145413025792] 2 task completed in the last 0.21 second(s)
...

At any point a single keyboard interrupt will stop the process:

[15:15:24 123145413025792] 2 task completed in the last 0.20 second(s)
^CTraceback (most recent call last):
  File "examples/backpressure.py", line 64, in <module>
    with_futureproof()
  File "examples/backpressure.py", line 40, in with_futureproof
    tm.map(fn, range(1_000_000_000))
  File "/Users/yeray/code/personal/futureproof/src/futureproof/task_manager.py", line 65, in __exit__
    self.run()
  File "/Users/yeray/code/personal/futureproof/src/futureproof/task_manager.py", line 93, in run
    for _ in self.as_completed():
  File "/Users/yeray/code/personal/futureproof/src/futureproof/task_manager.py", line 104, in as_completed
    yield self.wait_for_result()
  File "/Users/yeray/code/personal/futureproof/src/futureproof/task_manager.py", line 146, in wait_for_result
    completed_task = self._results_queue.get(block=True)
  File "/Users/yeray/.pyenv/versions/3.7.3/lib/python3.7/queue.py", line 170, in get
    self.not_empty.wait()
  File "/Users/yeray/.pyenv/versions/3.7.3/lib/python3.7/threading.py", line 296, in wait
    waiter.acquire()
KeyboardInterrupt
[15:15:24 123145413025792] 2 task completed in the last 0.20 second(s)
[15:15:24 123145413025792] 1 task completed in the last 0.10 second(s)
[15:15:24 123145413025792] Shutting down monitor...

Check out the examples directory for complete examples between futureproof and concurrent.futures on all these scenarios, simply run python examples/file.py and append futures to run the example using concurrent.futures.

Alternatives

I am by no means the first person to address these problems. Here a few similar, more stable and feature full, albeit restrictively licensed alternatives:

• Pebble, LGPL 3.0
• more-executors, GPL 3.0

futureproof is licensed MIT.