mapry 1.0.0.0rc1

Mapry

Mapry generates polyglot code for de/serializing object graphs from JSONable structures.

Story. We needed a yet another domain-specific language for internal data exchange and configuration of the system. The existing solutions mostly focused on modeling the configuration as object trees in which the data is nested in hierarchies with no cross-references between the objects. For example, think of object trees as JSON objects or arrays. We found this structure to be highly limiting for most of the complex messages and system configurations. Our use cases required objects in the data to be referenced among each other – instead of object trees we needed object graphs.

Moreover, we wanted the serialization itself to be readable so that an operator can edit it using a simple text editor. JSONable structure offered itself as a good fit there with a lot of existing assistance tools (JSON and YAML modules etc.).

Hence we developed Mapry, a generator that produces code to de/serialize object graphs from JSONable structures.

Maintainability. We wanted to facilitate maintainability of the system through as many static and run time checks as possible so that most errors in the object graphs are registered prior to the deployment in the production. These checks include strong typing annotations at generation time and various runtime checks at deserialization (dangling references, range checks, minimum number of elements in arrays, pattern matching etc.).

The schema of the object graph is stored in a separate JSON file and defines all the data types used in the object graph including the object graph itself. The code is generated based on the schema. You define schema once and you generate code in all the supported languages automatically. Schemas can be evolved and backward compatibility is supported through optional properties.

Versatility. Since we need humans to operate on object graphs, we needed the data representation of the object graph to be readable and editable. Hence we strived to make the resulting JSONable structures succinct yet comprehensible.

We intentionally did not fixate Mapry to directly handle files to allow for a larger variety of supported formats and sources (JSON, YAML, BSON, MongoDB etc.). Mapry operates on an in-memory representation of the JSONable data (such as Python dictionaries or Go map[string]interface{}) which makes it much more versatile than if it handled data sources directly.

Code readability over speed. We wanted the generated code to be rather readable than fast. Though the seasoned developers might not care about the implementation details, we found that newcomers really like to peek under the hub. They get up to speed much faster when the generated code is readable.

In particular, when the generated code permeates most of your system components, the readability becomes a paramount when you fix bottlenecks or debug.

Avoid dependency hell. We explicitly decided to make the generated code as stand-alone as possible. This includes generating redundant data structures such as parsing errors which could be theoretically used across different generated modules.

While this redundancy seems wasteful (duplication) or impractical (specific errors need to be checked instead of general ones), stand-alone code allows us to dispense of a common Mapry library which greatly alleviates the dependency hell in larger systems.

Take Protocol buffers as a contrasting example. The code generated by protocol buffers depends on a common protobuf library. Imagine you depend on two different libraries, each using a different version of protocol buffers. Since your system now has conflicting dependencies, there is usually no easy way to use both libraries in the system. If you are not the owner, you need to contact the maintainers of one of the libraries and ask them for an upgrade.

Rich set of primitives. We found that most of our data relied on a richer set of primitives than was provided by a standard JSON. We extended this set to include date, datetime, time of day, time zone, duration and path. These primitives greatly reduce the impedance mismatch between the data and program logic and spare us a lot of boiler-plate validation code.

Supported languages. Currently, Mapry speaks C++11, Go 1 and Python 3. Since the serialization needs to operate in different languages, only the intersection of language features is supported. For example, since Go does not support inheritance or union types, they are not supported in Mapry either.

Documentation

This document gives only a brief summary of Mapry. The full documentation can be found here: documentation <http://TODO>_.

Introduction

Let us introduce Mapry here by presenting an extensive example. We hope that this example would be enough to give you a first impression how to use the generator. To get the full picture and read all the details, get a list of available features, etc. please consult the documentation <http://TODO>_.

{
  "name": "Pipeline",
  "description": "defines an address book.",
  "cpp": {
    "namespace": "book::address",
    "path_as": "boost::filesystem::path",
    "optional_as": "std::experimental::optional",
    "datetime_library": "ctime"
  },
  "go": {
    "package": "address"
  },
  "py": {
    "module_name": "book.address",
    "path_as": "pathlib.Path",
    "timezone_as": "pytz.timezone"
  },
  "classes": [
    {
      "name": "Person",
      "description": "defines a contactable person.",
      "properties": {
        "full_name": {
          "type": "string",
          "description": "gives the full name (including middle names)."
        },
        "address": {
          "type": "Address",
          "description": "notes where the person lives."
        },
        "picture": {
          "type": "path",
          "description": "points to the image on the disk.",
          "pattern": "^/images/.*$",
          "optional": true
        },
        "birthday": {
          "type": "date",
          "description": "gives the birthday of the person in UTC."
        },
        "last_modified": {
          "type": "datetime",
          "description": "indicates the last modification timestamp."
        },
        "contact_period": {
          "type": "duration",
          "description": "gives a minimum period between two calls."
        },
        "friends": {
          "type": "map",
          "description": "lists friends of the person by nicknames.",
          "values": {
            "type": "Person"
          }
        },
        "active": {
          "type": "boolean",
          "description": "fires if the user is actively participating."
        },
        "height": {
          "type": "integer",
          "description": "gives height in centimeters.",
          "minimum": 0,
          "maximum": 300
        },
        "fee": {
          "type": "float",
          "description": "specifies the memebership fee in dollars.",
          "minimum": 0
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "embeds": [
    {
      "name": "Address",
      "description": "defines an address.",
      "properties": {
        "text": {
          "type": "string",
          "description": "gives the full address."
        },
        "time_zone": {
          "type": "time_zone",
          "description": "specifies the time zone of the address."
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "properties": {
    "maintainer": {
      "type": "Person",
      "description": "indicates the maintainer of the address book."
    }
  }
}

Json::Value value;
// ... parse the value from a source, e.g., a file

book::address::parse::Errors errors(1024);
book::address::Pipeline pipeline;

book::address::jsoncpp::pipeline_from(
    value,
    "/path/to/the/file.json#",
    &pipeline,
    &errors);

if (not errors.empty()) {
    for (const auto& err : errors.get()) {
        std::cerr << err.ref << ": " << err.message << std::endl;
    }
    return 1;
}

const Json::Value value(
        book::address::jsoncpp::serialize_pipeline(
            pipeline));

var value interface{}
// ... parse the value from a source, e.g., a file

pipeline := &address.Pipeline{}
errors := address.NewErrors(0)

address.PipelineFromJSONable(
    value,
    "#",
    pipeline,
    errors)

if !errors.Empty() {
    ee := errors.Values()
    for i := 0; i < len(ee); i++ {
        fmt.Fprintf(
            os.Stderr,
            "%s: %s\n",
            ee[i].Ref,
            ee[i].Message)
    }
    return 1
}

var err error
var jsonable map[string]interface{}
jsonable, err = address.PipelineToJSONable(pipeline)

value = json.loads(...)

errors = book.address.parse.Errors(cap=10)

pipeline = book.address.fromjsonable.pipeline_from(
    value=value,
    ref="#",
    errors=errors)

if not errors.empty():
    for error in errors.values():
        print("{}: {}".format(error.ref, error.message), file=sys.stderr)

    return 1

jsonable = book.address.tojsonable.serialize_pipeline(
    pipeline,
    ordered=True)

Usage

Mapry provides a single point-of-entry for all the code generation through mapry-to command.

To generate the code in different languages, invoke:

For C++:

For Go:

For Python:

If the output directory does not exist, it will be created. Any existing files will be silently overwritten.

Installation

We provide a prepackaged PEX file that can be readily downloaded and executed. Please see the Releases section.

If you prefer to use Mapry as a library (e.g., as part of your Python-based build system), install it as follows:

• Create a virtual environment:

python3 -m venv venv3

• Activate it:

source venv3/bin/activate

• Install Mapry with pip:

pip3 install mapry

Future Work

While Mapry satisfies very well many of our practical needs, there are countless possible improvement vectors. If you feel strong about any of the listed improvements (or you have another one in mind), please create an issue and help us discuss it.

New primitive types. We tried to devise a practical set of primitive types that covers most use cases. However, we do not know our (existing or potential) user base and our assumptions on what is necessary might be wrong.

New aggergated types. So far, we introduced only arrays and maps as aggregated types since they are JSON-native.

While JSON does not support aggregated types such as sets, the sets are at the core of many data models and would definitely merit a representation in Mapry. Please let us know your opinion about what would be a conventional way of representing sets in JSON.

Elaborate composite type system. We limited the composite type system to a graph, classes and embeddable structures for simplicity following Go’s approach (lack of inheritance, tuples and unions by design). We find optional fields to cover most of the use cases where inheritance, tuples or unions also fit.

Please feel free to convince us of the contrary and tell us how inheritance, tuples or unions should be handled. In particular, we do not really know what would be a conventional way of dealing with such a type system in Go.

Moreover, it is not clear to us how to deal with variance in aggregated types (covariance, contravariance or invariance) since different languages follow different approaches. Admittedly, we are a bit lost how to approach this issue and are open to suggestions.

Better contracts. We are convinced that contracts make data structures more maintainable and prevent many of the errors early. However, Mapry’s current contracts such as patterns and minimum/maximum are quite limited and need extensions. Please let us know which contracts you would welcome and how you would like to specify them.

Unfortunately, we can support only the most basic contracts. We do not have the time resources to include a declarative or imperative contract language that would automatically compile into the generated code. Notwithstanding the lack of time, we strongly believe that such a language would be beneficial and are open for cooperation if you think you could help us tackle that challenge.

Efficiency of de/serialization. Mapry was optimized for readability of generated code rather than the efficiency of de/serialization. Multiple improvements are possible here.

Obviously, the generated de/serialization code could be optimized while still maintaining the readability. Please let us know which practical bottlenecks you experienced so that we know where/how to focus our optimization efforts.

Since Mapry does not depend on the source of the JSONable data, you can already use faster JSON-parsing libraries (e.g., fastjson (Go) or orjson (Python)). However, in C++ setting where no standard JSONable structure exists, we could introduce an additional code generator based on faster JSON-parsing libraries such as rapidjson.

Fast de/serialization of character streams. Instead of operating on JSONable structures which are wasteful of memory and computational resources, we could generate de/serialization code that operates on streams of characters. Since schema is known, we could exploit that knowledge to make code work in one pass, be frugal in memory (e.g., consume only as much memory as is necessary to hold the object graph) and be extremely fast (since the data types are known in advance).

Additionally, when the language is slow (e.g., Python), the code can be made even faster by generating it in the most efficient language (e.g., C) together with a wrapper in the original language.

For an example of such an approach based on schema knowledge, see easyjson (Go).

Improve readability of generated code. While we find the generated code readable, the readability lies in the eye of the beholder. Please let us know which spots were hard for you to parse and how we could improve them.

Runtime checks at serialization. We designed Mapry to perform runtime validation checks only at deserialization since we envisioned its main input to be generated by humans. However, if you construct an object graph programmatically, you need to serialize it and then deserialize it in order to validate the contracts. While this works in cases with small data, it would be computationally wasteful on large object graphs.

We are thinking about introducing validation at serialization as well (triggered by a dedicated flag argument). Please let us know if you miss this functionality and what would you like to have covered.

Related Projects

We give here a non-comprehensive list of related de/serialization projects. We indicate how they differ from Mapry and explain why we took pains to develop (and maintain!) our own tool instead of using an existing one.

• Standard JSON libraries all support object trees, but not object graphs. Moreover, they do not support data based on a schema. While this is handy when the structure of your data is unknown at runtime, it makes code unnecessarily more difficult to maintain when the structure is indeed known in advance.

• There is a large ecosystem around structured objects and their serialization based on property annotations (e.g., Rapidschema (C++), encoding/json (Go) or Jackson (Java)). While some of them support handling object trees (usually through custom logic), we found the lack of polyglot support (and resulting maintenance effort required by synchronization of custom de/serialization rules across languages) a high barrier-to-usage.

• Standard or widely used serialization libraries such as Boost.Serialization (C++), Gob (Go) or Pickle (Python) serialize object graphs out-of-the-box and handle impedance mismatch well. However, the representation of the serialized data is barely human-readable and difficult to get right in a polyglot setting due to a lack of common poly-language libraries (e.g., reading pickled data structures in C++). We deemed it a Herculean task to maintain the corresponding de/serializations accross different languages.

• Popular serializers such as Protocol Buffers or Cap’n Proto support only object trees. If you need to work with cross-references in the serialized message, you need to dereference instances yourself. We found manual dereferencing in code to be error prone and lead to a substantial code bloat.

• Flatbuffers handle object graphs natively, but exhibit a great deal of impedance mismatch through lack of maps and sophisticated data types such as date/time, duration etc.

• Language-specific serializers such as ThorSerializer (C++), JavaScript Object Graph (Javascript), Serializr (Javascript) and Flexjson (Java) serialize object graphs with satisfying, but varying degree of structure enforcement and readability. Most approaches require the developer to annotate the structures with decorators which the libraries use to parse and serialize data. As long as you use a single-language setting and care about the data being readable, these solutions work well. However, it is not clear how they can be adapted to a multi-language setting where system components written in different languages need to inter-operate.

• JSON for Linking Data and JSON Graph are conventions to provide a systematic approach to modeling the object graphs in JSON. While these conventions look promising, we found the existing libraries lacking for production-ready code. On a marginal note, the JSON representations seem unnecessarily verbose when representing references.

• JVM serializers presents a report on different object serializers running on top of Java Virtual Machine. The serializers are evaluated based on their run time and size.

Development

We are very grateful for and welcome contributions: be it opening of the issues, discussing future features or submitting pull requests.

To submit a pull request:

• Check out the repository.

• In the repository root, create the virtual environment:

python3 -m venv venv3

• Activate the virtual environment:

source venv3/bin/activate

• Install the development dependencies:

pip3 install -e .[dev]

• Implement your changes.

• Run precommit.py to execute pre-commit checks locally.

# Create a separate virtual environment
python3 -m venv venv-cpp

# Activate it
. venv-cpp/bin/activate

# Install the dependencies of C++ live tests
pip3 install -e .[testcpp]

# Run the live tests
./tests/cpp/live_test_generate_jsoncpp.py

python3 -m venv venv-go
. venv-go/bin/activate
pip3 install -e .[testgo]
./tests/go/live_test_generate_jsonable.py

python3 -m venv venv-py
. venv-py/bin/activate
pip3 install -e .[testpy]./p
./tests/py/live_test_generate_jsonable.py

Versioning

We follow Semantic Versioning. We extended the standard semantic versioning with an additional format version. The version W.X.Y.Z indicates:

• W is the format version (data representation is backward-incompatible),

• X is the major version (library interface is backward-incompatible),

• Y is the minor version (library interface is extended, but backward-compatible), and

• Z is the patch version (backward-compatible bug fix).